Drew Barrymore, who’s one of PEOPLE’s 50th Anniversary cover stars ... You Never Figure It All Out' Most notably, a caricature of Barrymore sits atop the “50th PEOPLE” logo.

Naturally, the anniversary cake adhered to the same theme with several nods to PEOPLE’s past and present sprinkled on the dessert. Most notably, a caricature of Barrymore sits atop the “50th ...